PSL Source Baltimore Ravens PSLs
Ravens 20 Bengals 17 (OT)

Report Card Ravens 20 Bengals 17 (OT)

Posted in Report Card
8+ Comments Ed in ON says " The only thing i would say is that to me we have a better shot of going after the division then getting that last wildcard spot." This is totally untrue. T
Print this article

Many considered last week’s game against Cleveland to be a “must win.”  In a lot of circumstances it was, because a win against Cleveland and a win yesterday against the Bengals would have set Baltimore up for a much better shot to earn one of the final Wild Card playoff slots.

Right now, the playoff picture in the AFC looks like this: Cincinnati Bengals, New England Patriots, Kansas City Chiefs and the Indianapolis Colts leading their respective divisions.  The 5th and 6th playoff slots will (right now) be the Denver Broncos and New York Jets.  Yes, winning against the Bengals helped tremendously, but the Ravens pretty much have to win out for the rest of the year to have a solid shot at getting into the playoffs.  I’m not so sure that this current Ravens team will be able to accomplish that, even when the defense plays as well as they did yesterday.

Overall Team Grade: B.

The defense was flat out nasty for pretty much the entire game.  AJ Green did what AJ Green was going to do, but over 50 of his receiving yards came on that absurd fluke “Hail Mary” (or when you’re in Baltimore, Fail Mary) play that tied the game up and sent them into overtime.  Folks, don’t let the 17-0 score for much of the game fool you though.  The offense was gross for much of the game and they did a great job capitalizing on the Bengals committing penalties, but if it weren’t for those penalties I’m not so sure the offense would have done much at all.

Offensive Grades:  Overall, I’d probably grade the offense around a D+.

They did a great job scoring when they were in the red zone, but like I stated above, a lot of it had to do with the Bengals committing penalties.  They still can’t run the ball and Joe Flacco is still under far too much duress.  Short of a few interesting gadget plays – one to Tyrod Taylor and the other a Flea Flicker – the offense was still pretty bland and uninspiring.

Jim Caldwell, Grade: C-.

The gadget plays were too little, too late.  I can’t imagine that Caldwell is so oblivious that he can’t see what the issues on the offense are.  Zero second half points.  Not even a field goal.  What boggles my mind is that they just seem to continually be trying to force a square peg into a round hole.

Why are they taking Marlon Brown out on 3rd down plays?

Why are they running 15+ yards down field on a 3rd and 5 with absolutely NO underneath routes?

Finally, why are there no blitz-beating hot routes?  Every week there are free-runners at Flacco and he has no outlets, or so it seems.

Joe Flacco, 20/36, 140 yards 2 touchdowns 2 interceptions, Grade: C.

For the second week in a row, Flacco looked fairly off-target on a lot of his passes.  He missed Jacoby Jones on a deep pass again by under throwing the pass; however, it is possible that the wind may have impacted that throw because they were going into the wind.  Then, he overthrew Torrey Smith on another deep pass, which would have been a sure touchdown.  He also tried to force a couple of passes that should have been intercepted, but weren’t.  Still, Flacco has moments of sheer elite brilliance and his first touchdown pass to Dallas Clark was one of those moments.

Eugene Monroe, Grade: A-.

For the second week in a row, from my perspective, Monroe performed admirably.  He displayed nice footwork as a pass blocker and he did a nice job as a run blocker.  Monroe has to be a huge priority this off-season; perhaps even more than guys like Dennis Pitta.  The offensive line is a hot mess, but the acquisition of Monroe gives them the best left tackle they’ve had since Jon Ogden.

Ray Rice, 18 carries, 30 yards, 1.67 yards per carry, Grade: F.

Ray Rice claims he is 100% and over his hip injury.  If he is, then there is something serious going on because he is nothing short of disappointing.  From my perspective, I think the most glaring issue with Rice is that he is still trying to run the ball like he is a spry 24-year old who weighs 200lbs.  He isn’t that small anymore and I still think he can be an effective back, but he needs to learn how to run like a guy who is closer to 220lb side than 200lb.  That means instead of trying to shake a defender, who isn’t biting on it, he needs to lower his shoulder and run through it.  While Rice hasn’t been very good as a runner, his atrocious blocks are a big issue.  It has been multiple weeks now and Rice has whiffed on several blocks that have gotten Flacco destroyed.

Defensive Grades:  The defense was fantastic yesterday.  Grade: A+.

Other than a fluke play where James Ihedigbo tipped the Hail Mary pass right into AJ Green’s hands, the defense was excellent.  They made Andy Dalton look very average (which he is in my opinion) and the Bengals had a hard time getting anything going on the ground as well.  Even when Haloti Ngata went out with an injury, other guys like Terrance Cody, Art Jones and DeAngelo Tyson all stepped up.

James Ihedigbo, 2 interceptions, 6 tackles, Grade: A-.

The tipped pass was a huge error and a blemish on what was otherwise an outstanding day.  Ihedigbo looked like he was in the zone playing center field and it reminded me of Ed Reed in a lot of ways.  Ihedigbo has always been a guy who can come up and stuff the run, but his coverage skills have been called into question as of late.  There were a few breakdowns in coverage with Green, but overall I thought Ihedigbo played an excellent game.

Jimmy Smith, 4 tackles, multiple passes defensed, Grade: A.

A lot of folks still want to paint the “bust” pejorative all over Jimmy Smith every time he isn’t Deion Sanders in his prime out there.  However, to me, Jimmy has been the best defensive back on the team this year.  He has done well against a lot of top-flight receivers and he had some nice plays while covering Green yesterday.  Jimmy may not lead the NFL in interceptions, but he does a fine job in man-coverage.

Lardarius Webb, 5 tackles, 1 interception, Grade: A.

Frankly, I thought this was Webb’s best performance of the year.  He was flying around the field, knocking passes away and all things considered he did a nice job against the Bengals’ receivers.  One thing that I was pleased about was seeing Webb playing from the nickel position instead of Corey Graham.  Graham is much better suited as an outside corner, so having Webb line up as the nickel was a good choice.  I hope they stick with that for the rest of the season.

Dean Pees, Grade: A.

Why can’t Dean Pees produce a game plan like this each week?  The Bengals have a pretty darn good offense and the Ravens defenders gave them fits all day.  Suggs, Doom, Canty, Tyson, Art Jones, Ngata, McPhee, Upshaw, Daryl Smith and even Arthur Brown were constantly getting into the backfield and causing Dalton to throw the ball before he wanted to.  If it weren’t for a fluke play in the last seconds of the game, the Bengals wouldn’t have been close at all.

Special Teams Grades: B.

Justin Tucker kicked the game-winning field goal in a pressure situation. As always, Tucker is fantastic under pressure.  Additionally, the wind factor impacted a lot of the passing game and it also made an early field goal attempt by Mike Nugent sail to the left of the uprights.  Tucker’s kicks were true and he continues to show why he is one of the top kickers in the NFL, maybe even the best.  Regarding the return game, I would like to see them get some splash plays but as long as they aren’t putting the ball on the ground I can’t complain too much.

John Harbaugh, Grade: B-.

I thought John’s use of the challenges were brilliant.  I think Walt “I See Nothing” Coleman royally screwed him because Coleman clearly doesn’t understand the NFL rules for fumbles.  They ruled AJ Green was down, but the ball bounced out of his hands when the back of his hand was the only thing on the ground.  That is a fumble as per the NFL rules.

I thought this game plan was a lot better by the Ravens, but I still am really not impressed with the offensive performance (or lack thereof).  There are some obvious issues that I think could be easily fixed.  I know Harbs is a pretty risk-averse coach, but he of all people should know that sometimes drastic changes are necessary to get the most out of everyone.

Right now the Ravens are 4-5 in a division where the leading team is 6-4.  The problem is there are nine other teams that have as good or better records as the Ravens and Baltimore still has games against Pittsburgh, Detroit, Chicago, Minnesota and another Bengals match up.  That is not a cakewalk schedule by any stretch of the imagination and with the way the offense is playing, I’m not so sure they’ll be able to get to the playoffs.

GIFs c/o Gordon Dixon

Share This  
Paul Lukoskie

About Paul Lukoskie

Paul (aka WickedSolo) has been an avid football fan since he was a little kid. As former player himself (through college only...turning pro and having million dollar contracts and fame just sounded too overwhelming...or he's just a 5'11" 200lb guy who was only good enough to play D-3 ball...but who's counting...) he has a ton of experience in the locker room, on the field, and in the film room during the off-season and the regular season. While serving in the US Navy on active duty he had the opportunity to check out the Senior Bowl in Mobile, Alabama and caught the attention of a few Ravens' scouts (not too hard to spot the only guy in Mobile wearing camo fatigues with a purple Ed Reed jersey) and they were kind enough to point out some of the things they look for when scouting players. From that point on, Paul was hooked on the draft and everything leading up to it. He regularly contributes draft-based analytical pieces on the RSR forum and is constantly providing Ravens fans with collegiate players to check out. Paul is a Charm City native through and through and after being Honorably discharged from the Navy lives with his wife Ashly and son Jack. Jack is less than a year old, but is in the process of training to play for the Ravens in 2033. More from Paul Lukoskie
Ed in ON
Ed in ON

" The only thing i would say is that to me we have a better shot of going after the division then getting that last wildcard spot." This is totally untrue. The 2nd WC spot is held by the Jets, who hasnt strung together 2 consecutive wins all season long and has an even more pathetic offense than us. We are only 1 game back on them with a h2h meeting, so we can easily take them if we can pull it together. The Bengals still have 1.5 games on us with 1 h2h matchup left.

Mike M
Mike M

I don't really buy into this whole 'We must win out the season to be in the mix' nonsense. Is everyone else watching a different AFC than me each weekend? The AFC is so damn weak this year a team will make it in at 9-7 in the final wildcard spot. That allows for 2 games to be given up within the final 7 weeks. That's not that unreasonable all things considering. And keep in mind that the final Wildcard spot probably won't go to Miami in the heat of all this turmoil, it probably won't go to Tennessee since they are just as unpredictable week in and week out, and it probably won't go to Cleveland because they're riding on momentum and someone will take the wind out of their sail shortly. The only other team missing from this list is SD who still have two matches against KC and one more in Denver and the Jets who we play in a few weeks, which would give us a tiebreaker over them with a win. The AFC is incredibly weak aside from a few contenders and the AFC North is at the epicentre of that with a divisional crown probably going to a team with a 9-7 or 10-6 record considering how poorly all four teams have been playing. If the Ravens take Chicago, three games in a row will be played at home against sub-par teams. Why is it so far fetched for them to roll into the playoffs?


Ray Rice is clearly hurting. I can speak from experience, that when your hips get stiff, you lose explosiveness and lateral quickness. Take it for what it's worth but I've been told that he has a torn labrum. I tore my labrum and recognize what I'm seeing from Rice out there on the field. It's common for shifty backs that rely on lateral quickness to trash their hips over years of juking and sliding around tacklers. When a RB loses "it" it's usually because his hip area stiffens up and he loses a step. Unfortunately, it looks like this has happened to Rice.


I agree with your grades Paul. The only thing i would say is that to me we have a better shot of going after the division then getting that last wildcard spot. Cincy is not that good and they have lost key critical defenders in Atkins, Hall and Mays. Dalton is in a rut right now. Lets see what happens next week between Cleveland and Cincy but hopefully these guys still believe they can win the division


The Ravens also have tough home games against the Jets and Patriots left; the author left these out of his article. The schedule is brutal!

Voice of Reason
Voice of Reason

The Ravens will only go as far as the running game takes them. Flacco has always depended on a balanced attack in order to keep defenders off of him. He is not the type of QB that can carry a team, as few are. He is good in the clutch as long as the other pieces are working for him. Ray Rice looks like he is at the end of his career, sadly. Even in open space, he does not have the speed or elusiveness that he once had. What are the Ravens to do? His contract is really a noose around our neck at this point and we may be stuck with him another year. We desperately need to upgrade the O-line and running back position.


Its time to move Ray Rice out of the backfield and have him in the slot where he can get in open space and make some moves on the slower linebackers. I have always questioned his blocking skills and now its clearly a major problem. He has lost the explosiveness in his first step and that is why he is not hitting the open holes.


Better bring in someone to fill in for Ray Rice until he gets his SHT together. They can't do any worse.


Your browser is out-of-date!

Update your browser to view this website correctly.

Get More Information