Aaron Mellette and Marlon Brown Continue Seesaw Battle

brownseesaw

In what has been a lackluster training camp for the wide receiver position (after Torrey Smith), two bright spots have been a couple rookies.

Aaron Mellette and Marlon Brown are two players that have at least given the wide receiver position a pulse this preseason. With so many struggling above them on the depth chart, both have not only shown up during practice, they’ve also put together some impressive game film.

Having watched this battle closely throughout the preseason, it appears that each player has one-upped the other at various points throughout training camp, but neither have gained separation.

Draft

The Ravens didn’t invest much into Mellette, using one of their two seventh-round picks on the Elon University receiver. By drafting Mellette, the team assured that he’d at least be invited to their training camp and other teams wouldn’t have an option to recruit him during the undrafted free agency scramble after the draft.

For Brown, the story was different. It was a stroke of luck that he ended up in the Ravens’ training camp. Brown originally chose to join the Houston Texans, but somewhere along the line there was a snag and he ended up in Baltimore instead.

“We recruited him like crazy,” Harbaugh said about Brown. “We really liked him from the beginning. [When] I saw him, he jumped off the tape.”

If Brown wasn’t coming off a torn ACL suffered in his final year at Georgia, he certainly would have been drafted. Luckily, the stars aligned and the Ravens got a very good talent and it didn’t cost them a draft pick.

Advantage: Mellette

Running With The First Team

Last Sunday, the Ravens gave Torrey Smith a day off. The purpose, though, wasn’t just to rest Smith; they were trying to see what type of rapport the rookies could build with quarterback Joe Flacco. With Jacoby Jones on one side, Brown got first crack with the starters.

Throughout the week, each player had their fair share of reps working with Flacco.

When it came time to enter the game, Mellette was the first rookie receiver to join the first team, replacing Jones.

Advantage: Mellette

Game Film

Brown scored his first touchdown of the preseason on Thursday against the Panthers. In total, Brown led the Ravens receivers in all three major categories with his four catches for 59 yards and a touchdown. His showing was even more impressive because even though the Panthers’ secondary isn’t one of the best, they are NFL starters. Mellette, on the other hand, has flourished against backups.

Speaking of Mellette, he had a sub-par night, catching only two passes for nine yards.

Here are their stats through three preseason games:

Games Targeted Catches Yards TD YPC
Aaron Mellette 3 5 4 70 2 17.5
Marlon Brown 2 9 6 90 1 15

When it comes to their style of play, Mellette has displayed good footwork at times and with a little coaching, can likely improve his route running and moves to lose cornerbacks. Mellette has made more plays than just catching a pair of touchdowns; he’s also drawn multiple pass interference penalties. However, I’ve seen that Mellette struggles with getting separation which is why his touchdowns looked so good – he was well covered.

Brown is a big target (6-5, 205) and at least to me, shows better seperation skills at this point. Given the amount of times he’s been targeted and his success in fewer games, you’d have to think his game film is better at this point.

Advantage: Brown

What Will The Ravens Do?

As it stands now, this competition is too close to call in my opinion. If I had to pick, I think Brown would be the safest option at this point to make the 53-man roster. His size is too good to pass up, he worked more from the slot (a position the Ravens have struggled with) and he’s proven he can play with the first team.

For Mellette and Brown, they’ll have to treat each practice as if it was a game because this battle is equivalent to a two-minute drive to get into field goal range for the win.

I can’t envision the Ravens letting either of these players reach their practice squad because they’re likely to be claimed by another team. More likely than not, the one player will earn a spot on the 53-man roster, and another will be placed on injured reserve to protect them as a project for this season as the Ravens did with Tommy Streeter last year. But, unlike Streeter, these players have NFL potential.

Expect a hangnail to pop up after Thursday’s preseason finale against the St. Louis Rams. As for who gets it, that depends on another week’s worth of practice and game film.

This entry was posted in Blog View, Camp Notes, Featured by Kris Jones. Bookmark the permalink.

About Kris Jones

Kris Jones
Kris - or "Goob" as he's widely known - has turned an obsession into a career. As a media member by day and super fan by night, he reports from the Under Armour Performance Center twice per week and brings Ravens news from a fan's perspective. His popular YouTube series...more

13 Raves on “Aaron Mellette and Marlon Brown Continue Seesaw Battle

    • Kris JonesKris Jones on said:

      What’s wrong? I can’t have a little fun with horrific photoshop skills. Some people are definitely visual learners and don’t like reading. haha

  1. Mill on said:

    Marlon Brown just seems a bit more polished at this point. His awareness of the first down marker, his route running, his ability to separate. He is just a more polished player than Mellette. It is not like the Ravens are going to go with Mellette over Brown just because Mellette was the draft pick. Look no further than last season when Thompson, initially, made the active roster over Streeter. They both ended up on IR nut Streeter was sent during the preseason and Thompson was sent after actually playing in a few games.

  2. J.O. on said:

    Both should make the team….it should be torrey, jacoby, stokely, dt, brown, mellette and laquan if they go with seven. Tandon doss has done nothing to deserve a roster spot whatsoever.

    • J.B. on said:

      Perfect! Couldn’t have said it better myself! Cut Doss! I’m also glad that we gave up on Reid (sp), he was always injured and couldn’t be trusted in the return game because of turnovers.

    • Anonymous on said:

      What vet? Brandon Lloyd? Not sure there is anyone left out there that would/could help us, and after seeing Brown step up the way he did, I think he is our best bet.

  3. Ravcolt on said:

    Brown looks to be the real deal. His TD catch was instinctual. And in today’s NFL the middle of the field is where safeties are not allowed to hit. He needs to be with the first string eventually. Can he go deep?

  4. D rock on said:

    They really may go 7 receivers. I think it’s the best option. Keep Brown and Mellette. A year on the team and not IR will do both good.

  5. KillaBirdTJ on said:

    Why cant they BOTH make the 53 man Roster???? The only reciever that has performed better than these two is Torrey Smith. Jones, Doss, Streeter, and Thompson should be behind both of them on the depth chart. Being a rookie shouldn’t mean one has to be IR’ed! It’s simple… let the best players play!

  6. Arthur on said:

    Considering the lack of talent above them of the depth charts it would be wise to keep both… There of pleanty of good candidates to be released.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

 

Hot off the street

Ravens Should Give McClain Another Shot

So Rolando McClain showed up late for a workout in front of Ravens’ officials yesterday and then promptly failed his conditioning test. Same old Rolando? Maybe, maybe not. It’s easy to as...read more

Ravens Round 1 Draft Profile: Zack Martin

The third player profile in our series centers on the best of South Bend in 2013. Zach Martin, former offensive lineman for the Fighting Irish, played multiple positions along the offensive line durin...read more

McClain Comeback Has a Setback

Don’t hold your breath waiting for inside linebacker Rolando McClain’s return to the Ravens. According to NFL Network, McClain showed up late for a Tuesday workout with the Ravens, and failed t...read more

Tuesday’s Roundup: Smith & Webb Talk Trash

Charges Against Deonte Thompson Dropped Two months ago, wide receiver Deonte Thompson was arrested on suspicion of possession of drug paraphernalia and marijuana in Gainesville, Florida. Over the wee...read more

Could Ravens Go “All Irish” Early in 2014 Draft?

The Ravens have done a lot this offseason to surround quarterback Joe Flacco with more options in the passing game, and to provide him with better protection to give him more time in the pocket. Re...read more

View More