Game Thread: Giants @ Ravens

[Dont Know]

You are correct but as I stated on the previous page receivers have to maintain control through the full catch including going to and through a fall to the ground.

I don't like it but that's the rule.

That's if you are making a catch in the endzone. He didn't, he caught it outside and broke the plane. That's a TD.

[ActualSpamBot]

Upshaw clipped on that play. No call.

[DarienA]

Not when the catch is made outside the endzone. Then the mere act of crossing the plane ends the play. Refs got it wrong, even Perrira said so.

Personally it feels like the rules for receivers change every week. I can barely keep up.

Slight aside... board slow to load/refresh for anybody else?

[Irish Raven]

Mike Periera knows what he's talking about

I can't ever remember him making a call and the refs doing the opposite

I sometimes think a team should hire him and advise the head coach on challenges!

[akashicrecorder]

You are correct but as I stated on the previous page receivers have to maintain control through the full catch including going to and through a fall to the ground.

I don't like it but that's the rule.

Where as RB's can just run in and as soon as they get in its a TD, receivers have to do more.

Again, I don't think that is right. Once a receiver catches the ball and starts running, he is a runner. Jacoby caught the ball, got two feet down and spun. He's a runner at that point because he's established possession. A break of the plane should be all it takes.

By the way, sorry if my last post came off harsh. I was/am just pissed about that awful call.

[bacchys]

Personally it feels like the rules for receivers change every week. I can barely keep up.

Slight aside... board slow to load/refresh for anybody else?

Sometimes it seems to change between quarters...or even possessions.

It's slow for me, too.

[MickieB-OM]

Turnover, turnover, turnover.

[DarienA]

By the way, sorry if my last post came off harsh. I was/am just pissed about that awful call.

I didn't take it personally believe me I'm not thrilled either. I personally think it was a touchdown as well. I think receiver catch rules in general are too convoluted at this point.

[DarienA]

Refs got the PI call right... thank goodness.

[MickieB-OM]

Offensive PI--yep, good call.

[Jsmoove]

refs afre a fuckin joke they are making up for that bullshit call

[DarienA]

That was a fumble... incomplete pass my a$$.

[TTRaven]

That's a fumble

[ActualSpamBot]

Hixon didn't catch that anyway. Penalty is meaningless. Ball was bobbling on the ground.

Which Raven is hurt?!

Hope this call stands, I think we lost the ball at the end which would be a giant first down.

[Irish Raven]

Challenge!

[StingerNLG]

At first I was going to blast Brown for that, but now I see why he couldn't play the ball. Nice call.

And another punt coming for the giants.

[akashicrecorder]

Haha, good challenge, Coughlin.

If Eli fumbled it, we stupidly fumbled it back.

[DarienA]

I cannot believe Upshaw couldn't hold on to that ball....

[CodyPKA]

these refs are a joke. thats not even close to a pass attempt

[Jsmoove]

Wow coughlin you made harbaugh look very good lmao!!