If David Carr Is Cut, Would You Sign Him?

[purplepoe]

Right now Mcnair is the guy. I haven't changed my stance on that. IF boller plays better, which in the past he has proven he can not, then I say lets keep him. Sort of in a true sense of a Yankee fan; Play like crap you get ridiculed, play well you get praised,


You should read a little closer and see what was said. Don't put words in my mouth.


And I haven't felt this way? Dude stop trying to be the self righteous Baltimore ravens fan. Enough with that BS. I get it ,you come from Baltimore and you are all things Baltimore. You eat the best Chicken Boxes, You go to O's Games, you Eat at the best snowball establishments,enjoy eating crabs and all the girls you want to date have the herps.....sit down and zip it already.

I am a fan of this team. You know this to be true. I'm a loyal fan who was able to snag tickets, I wont give them up for nothing.


That may be true but the topic of this thread is titled "If David Carr Is Cut, Would You Sign Him?" Poe lets stay on topic.



Poe How many times have I said if he cant prove his worth we should trade him? this is his final year and his last shot. Do I want him to do well as a Raven, YES. Do you? I don't think you do. You just want to say hey look I was right regardless of how it affects the ravens. But you have the balls to questions my loyalty to the team. what always separated me from all the bashers, like you, is that I always showed Boller compassion. You wanted Boller off the team no matter what with out a trade or getting something for him. You have always been in a dark place. Not me.

Did I enjoy all the takes on boller, sure they were all interesting--even tex's, regardless of what Greg is campaigning.

1. Why would you trade him when he's in the last year of his contract and we have nobody else.

2. I would've loved if Boller panned out. It would've made all of our lives easier as Ravens fans.

3. I never questioned your loyalty as a fan. I just think you're a shitty fan. Talk about making shit up. I just showed how you flip flop at the drop of a hat with your crying about "McNoodle" and then saying how you enjoy reading Boller bashing. It shows that you won't stick to your guns. Stop playing semantics. Your crap has worn thin here for months. So you enjoy "reading" Boller bashing. There, I corrected it.

4. It's not about being from Baltimore or being all things Baltimore. You're dig at the city just shows how absolutely lame you really are. And thanks for the laugh about showing Boller compassion.

5. I know what the topic is. If Tomlinson gets cut tomorrow, would you take him? I would. But it's a far fetched idea that isn't happening. Just like Carr.

6. You are a true Yankee fan. You've shown that over and over. You "ridicule" a player if he doesn't perform up to your standards. That pretty much says it all.

PP

[crazyraven]

I never questioned your loyalty as a fan. I just think you're a shitty fan.

Poe, I don't get you. Why would you say I was a shitty fan. I go to great lengths to go to the games and follow the team. Especially coming from NOVA, I can tell you its not that easy. If you don't like me because of what I say on a message board, I guess you are entitled to do that but I have to say you are far off. You use to agree with the things I wrote about boller and now you are attacking me because I have slightly changed modes. In hindsight you were also very buddy buddy with guys like stinger, Never once did I say you were a shitty fan because of that. anyways, So I went after mcnair for having a boller like game at home, in the playoffs. I was pissed, and even so, I always maintained that Mcnair deserves the start, unless he is beat out next season.

You're dig at the city just shows how absolutely lame you really are.

Oh I'm really lame? Ok I got it, You know I'm from new york and you take shots at New Yorkers but I cant do the same to baltimoronians (sp) ? Then you come to me all teary eyed crying foul...Come on man, toughen up.

[purplepoe]

Poe, I don't get you. Why would you say I was a shitty fan. I go to great lengths to go to the games and follow the team. Especially coming from NOVA, I can tell you its not that easy. If you don't like me because of what I say on a message board, I guess you are entitled to do that but I have to say you are far off. You use to agree with the things I wrote about boller and now you are attacking me because I have slightly changed modes. In hindsight you were also very buddy buddy with guys like stinger, Never once did I say you were a shitty fan because of that. anyways, So I went after mcnair for having a boller like game at home, in the playoffs. I was pissed, and even so, I always maintained that Mcnair deserves the start, unless he is beat out next season.


Oh I'm really lame? Ok I got it, You know I'm from new york and you take shots at New Yorkers but I cant do the same to baltimoronians (sp) ? Then you come to me all teary eyed crying foul...Come on man, toughen up.

You've proven yourself lately on this board.

I don't need to address this anymore.

PP

[jonboy79]

I would take Garcia, Culpepper, Garrard or Leftwich (whomever is the backup) Brunell, Plummer, Collins, Griese, Brad Johnson, Frerotte, and even Chris Simms over Boller as a backup. So how you can say he is among the top couple backups I have no clue. He and Anthony Wright would be bottom feeders in my estimation. They both are among the worst in the league. Sorry, but Boller as a backup isn't any better than Boller as a starter who sucked. He's still playing the same damn position just fortunately for us Ravens fans not nearly as often.

Well, Culpepper will be starting, Plummer is retired and I would take Boller over everyone else on your list, including Garcia who will be starting. That's how. Gimme another list maybe I'll pick another one or two. Funnily enough I think Quinn Gray maybe the best QB on JAX's roster.

[hurting]

Boller isn't even the best backup the Ravens have had on their roster. Dilfer is that guy by a wide margin. Boller, Banks, Blake, Wright, you could put them all in a bag and shake any of them out and there would be no discernable difference in their QB play.

"Mr. Ritter, what you've just said is one of the most insanely idiotic things I have ever heard. At no point in your rambling, incoherent response were you even close to anything that could be considered a rational thought. Everyone in this room is now dumber for having listened to it. May God have mercy on your soul."

[crazyraven]

If there was a team All time back-up list, the ravens would have to put dilfer somewhere near the top. Not sure if Boller even gets much attention as a starter or as a backup.