Matt Ryan or Joe Flacco?

Ryan Flacco

Matt Ryan or Joe Flacco?

Who is better?

It’s a question that has been asked over and over since the pair of first round quarterbacks were selected in the 2008 NFL Draft.

Their numbers have been compared and debated along with their respective supporting casts.

Ryan supporters will say that Flacco has had the luxury of playing with a better defense which could help mask some of the signal caller’s flaws. Flacco supporters will say that Ryan plays at least 9 of his games each season in domes and at least 2 others in very temperate climates and therefore his numbers should be better.

Ryan backers will argue that he was forced to carry the Falcons, clean up the mess left behind by Michael Vick and that his maturation is more evident than Flacco’s. Those in Flacco’s camp will point to the number of playoff wins that the strong-armed former Delaware Blue Hen has under his belt and then remind us all of the former Boston College Eagle’s post season struggles.

The debate has no clear winner.

The debate also found its way into the Ravens war room on draft day 2008.

Ravens owner Steve Bisciotti wanted a franchise quarterback. He believed that in order to keep the window of opportunity open from year to year that the Ravens needed proficiency and consistency at the game’s most important position.

And Matt Ryan was his guy.

But the Ravens scouts and coaching staff were well aware of Flacco’s gun-slinging capabilities. And while they all liked Ryan, the consensus was that the differences between the two weren’t worth the enormous cost to move into position (from the 8th pick to the 3rd pick) to make Matt Ryan a Raven.

To move up five spots the Ravens would have had to sacrifice their first, second, third and fourth round picks according to the NFL Trade Value Chart. Instead the Ravens did their wheeling and dealing with the Jaguars, Texans and Seahawks to eventually get in position to select Joe Flacco and Ray Rice.

The balance of the draft didn’t produce much for the Ravens. Tavares Gooden, Tom Zbikowski, Oniel Cousins, Marcus Smith, David Hale, Haruki Nakamura, Justin Harper and Allen Patrick made marginal contributions at best and none is currently a member of the team.

But at the end of the day, the Ravens got their franchise quarterback without relinquishing a king’s ransom, along with a helping of Rice.


Regular Season Statistical Comparison

QB Att Comp % Yds TD INT QBR R/Att * Yds TD W-L
Flacco 2210 1340 60.6 15653 89 52 85.7 182 437 5 49-22
Ryan 2287 1414 61.8 16256 112 52 90.1 186 444 5 50-19


* Rushing Attempts

Note: Flacco has started 71 regular season games; Ryan 69


Post Season Statistical Comparison

QB Att Comp % Yds TD INT QBR R/Att Yds TD W-L
Flacco 247 134 54.3 1532 8 8 70.4 34 63 1 5-4
Ryan 110 70 63.6 584 3 4 71.2 8 9 0 0-3


2008 NFL Draft day trade notes

  • Baltimore traded its first-round (No.8) pick to Jacksonville for the Jaguars’ first- (No. 26); two third- (No. 71) and (No. 89) and fourth-round (No. 125) picks. Jacksonville selected Derrick Harvey, de, Florida. Baltimore traded No. 26 and No. 89 to Houston and selected (No. 71) and (No. 125).
  • Houston traded its first-round (No. 18) pick to Baltimore for the Ravens’ first- (No.26); third- (No. 89) and sixth-round (No. 173) picks. Baltimore selected Joe Flacco, qb, Delaware. Houston selected Duane Brown, ot, Virginia Tech; (No. 89) and (No. 173).
  • Baltimore traded its second-round (No. 38) to Seattle for the Seahawks’ second- (No. 55) and third-round (No. 86) picks. Seattle selected John Carlson, te, Notre Dame. Baltimore selected Ray Rice, rb, Rutgers and (No. 86).

5 Raves on “Matt Ryan or Joe Flacco?

  1. Sauce on said:

    Heard Joe’s comments about the no-huddle and not throwing it out.

    Joe needs to worry less about his contract and the no huddle offense and more about winning.

    Look at how the Steelers have gotten back on track this year, RUNNING the ball. Th

    They better give the ball to Ray Rice 20 times against Cleveland or they will lose again… guaranteed…

    Running also helps a defense that has holes and issues like ours does now…

  2. JerryB on said:

    When you consider the personnel that Ryan has had to work with versus the personnel Joe has had to work with, the pendulum swings in Joe’s favor as having done more with less! Add to that fact that Joe has played in an inconsistent offense coached by an inept coordinator and, again, Flacco’s performance has transcended both deficits. Remember, he’s not only won playoff games, but has twice come within one game of a Super Bowl appearance, which is considerably more than Ryan has produced in the same time frame!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>


Hot off the street

PRACTICE NOTES: Bynes Released, Webb & J. Smith Return

As the Ravens prepare this week to open the the 2014 NFL season against the Cincinnati Bengals, they do so with all 53 players on the practice field, a good sign everyone is healthy and ready to go. more

ASK THE CAP MAN: What’s the “Rule of 51?”

(1/2) Ravens are currently $8,392,818 under the Salary Cap, but that is Ruleof51 #, which ends at 4:00 tomorrow. After that, they all count— Brian McFarland (@RavensSalaryCap) September 2, 2014 more

Ravens 2014 TV & Radio Programming

Ravens Wired, presented by Bose ·       Tuesdays at 5 p.m. and 11:30 p.m. on Comcast SportsNet ·       Tuesdays at 7:30 p.m. and 10:30 p.m. on MeTV Baltimore (WBAL-TV; more

FANTASY LINKS: Pick Up Taliaferro

15 Fantasy Football Transactions for Week 1 "We’re back. Fantasy football is back. And that means weekly start-sit decisions, waiver wire adds and emotional ups and downs that you’d only find more

Ravens Predictions For The 2014 Season

Biggest Surprise: To say that the position of cornerback is thin for the Baltimore Ravens is about as insightful as saying ESPN slobbers over Johnny Manziel. Starters Jimmy Smith and Lardarius Webb more

View More