PERCEPTION IS REALITY: Home Field Advantage is an Oxymoron

Dalton takes field in Cincinnati

Reality: The Wild Card games averaged 34.7 million viewers… making it the most-watched Wild Card Weekend ever. The 49ers/Packers was the most-watched Wild Card game ever, averaging 47.1 million viewers.

Perception: The NFL continues to be the biggest thing in America. It doesn’t matter who plays or what day of the week… the NFL wins the TV ratings battle every week. And what’s even more remarkable is the demos it wins… all of them! Men, Women, Young, Old… the NFL is the most watched anything on television. The NFL can do no wrong right now.

Reality: The NFL is discussing adding more teams to the playoffs.

Perception: As I said, the NFL can do no wrong… or can it? The NFL Season is perfect! Why mess with a good thing? And right now, the NFL playoffs are perfect. But the NFL wants to make even more money, so they have talked about adding more playoff games and adding more regular season games. Don’t re-seed. Don’t add more playoff teams. Don’t add more regular season games. I know probably all of these things will change, but it shouldn’t. The NFL season is just right, right now! But money talks and the owners will find a way to make more.

Reality: Home-field advantage is important in the NFL… but it’s not that important.

Perception: Usually, home field is seen as a big advantage in the NFL. However, if not for the Colts overcoming a 28-point deficit, all four road teams would have won on Wildcard Weekend. Plus, 5 of the last 10 teams that went undefeated at home during the regular season, lost their initial home playoff game. So as much as home field advantage really is an advantage in the NFL, it seems to be neutralized somewhere come playoff time.

Image courtesy of Grantland.com

Reality: #6 seeds are 6-2 against #1 seeds since 2005.

Perception: That’s good news for the Saints and Chargers, who are the #6 seeds this year. No. 1 seeds are 7-9 in the Divisional Playoffs since 2005. In fact, since the NFL went to an eight-division format in 2002, there has only been one #1 vs #1 seed in the Super Bowl and that was the Saints / Colts four years ago. The Seahawks went to the Super Bowl as a #1 seed in 2005, but lost to the #6 Steelers. So overall, being a lower seed in the NFL playoffs is not a bad thing at all.

And in the AFC, it’s even more interesting. There are 4 AFC teams left in the playoffs… the Broncos and the 3 teams the Broncos lost to this season. So the Super Bowl really is up for grabs for any team that plays well this weekend.

Reality: For the first time since the 2009 season, no AFC North team will be in the AFC Championship Game.

Perception: The Ravens and the Steelers have been at the top of the AFC for many years. This year, neither made the playoffs, and the Bengals were pretenders. It makes it a bit harder for me to decide who to root for when no AFC North teams are in the playoffs to root against.

Reality: The Cincinnati Bengals haven’t won a playoff game since January 6, 1991.

Perception: The Bengals continue to be the Bungals in the playoffs. Yes, they just completed the best 5-year stretch in their 46-year history. But they are winless in their last 5 playoff games. They have not won a playoff game since 1991. In comparison, the Ravens have 14 playoff wins since 1991, and they didn’t exist for the first 5 years of that time frame.

It really is amazing just how bad the Bengals (and the Browns) have been in the AFC North. Bengals head coach Marvin Lewis has coached them since 2003, which is the 2nd longest tenured coach in the league (behind Bill Belichick of the Patriots). But Lewis is only 90-90-1 and is 0-5 in the playoffs. Lewis and Jim Mora (when he coached the Saints) are the only men to coach a team for 11 years and never win a playoff game.

I am all for owners who stick with coaches through the tough times. I think the better organizations in the long term are the ones that don’t flip coaching staff’s often. See the Patriots and the Steelers as examples.

But sooner or later, the Bengals will need to make a switch if Lewis can’t get them over the hump… and I’m not talking Super Bowl… I’m simply saying win a single playoff game.

This entry was posted in Blog View, Featured by Joe Polek. Bookmark the permalink.

About Joe Polek

Joe Polek
Joe Polek was born in Baltimore, MD, and was raised in Bel Air, MD. In 2001, he moved to Portland, Maine for a job in radio. In 2012, he moved to Columbia, SC for another gig in radio, where he currently resides with his wife, Nicole, and their two daughters....more

4 Raves on “PERCEPTION IS REALITY: Home Field Advantage is an Oxymoron

  1. Dominic K. on said:

    Someone should tell Mr. Barnwell that the Colts played in Baltimore in the 2006 playoffs. They played the Patriots at home.

  2. Reading Comments on said:

    Mike Brown is a tool. Look at Angelos and tell me the Orioles are going to win something as long as he owns the team?
    It’s ownership!!!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

 

Hot off the street

FILMSTUDY: Pass Rush Reminiscent of 2006

Defensive Notes vs. Falcons 10/19/14 The Ravens received solid performances from a number of defenders who will be central to their 2nd half push en route to a 29-7 thrashing of the Falcons. The a...read more

RAVENS REPORT CARD: Ravens 29, Falcons 7

Ravens Take Over 1st Place in AFC North Overall: B+ Defense was great, Offense did enough and they were up 20 – 0 after 3 quarters. Atlanta is a bad team and good teams dominate bad ones and tha...read more

KNEE-JERK REACTIONS: Ravens Cruise in Battle of Birds

The Ravens were clearly the better team but a sloppy second half by the home team kept the game mildly interesting for folks not rooting for the birds in black. Hopefully Eugene Monroe returns next we...read more

This Week on Russell Street

GO BOLD! Some of our staff predictions admittedly have been pretty whack! Some of you have said we’re homers…well at least one of you always says so. Do you think these BOLD PREDICTIONS are any b...read more

LOOK OVER HERE: Cryin’ Matt Ryan on Sunday?

Things to look for on Sunday when you aren't watching the ball... Me & Julio: Julio is the name of my friend’s African Grey parrot but a bird of greater interest on Sunday is Falcons’ WR Ju...read more

View More