Time to say goodbye to Ed Reed

reedlombardi

It wasn’t until the confetti started falling on the players’ heads in the Superdome that I realized Ray Lewis had just played in his final NFL game. I thought to myself the city of Baltimore has just lost the face of their franchise. I’m going to assume that most Ravens fans believe the torch will be momentarily passed to Ed Reed, despite his free agent status heading into the offseason. However, there are several reasons why I don’t believe the Ravens front office should bring back one of the great safeties to ever play professional football. Am I crazy? Let’s look at the facts.

 

Diminishing Skills

“Father time will always be undefeated” – Charles Barkley

Reed had hip surgery in 2010 and last October he let the media know he was playing through a torn shoulder labrum. Both of these injuries (according to my physical therapist wife) will severely affect your range of motion and cause pain during certain movements after the injury heals. Even the most casual Ravens fan has noticed Ed’s lack of tackling skills. He’s also not as quick to the ball as he’s been in years past and several errant throws that would have been interceptions in previous years fell harmlessly to the turf. Ed Reed is one of the toughest guys in the Baltimore locker room. The perception that he’s “lazy” or “doesn’t care” stems from these injuries, not from his lack of desire. He just isn’t the player he used to be and his play on the field is indicative of that.

Salary Cap Implications

The former Miami Hurricane made $7.7 million in 2012 and despite saying it’s “not about the money,” that’s exactly what it’s about in the business of the NFL. I doubt his pride will allow him to take much of a pay cut heading into 2013. The NFL Salary Cap for 2013 is $121,500,000 and a giving Reed 6-7 million dollars with Suggs’ and Ngata’s bloated cap figures currently on the books won’t leave much room to keep guys like Paul Kruger and Dannell Ellerbe. That’s not even considering the huge deal that it will take to keep Joe Flacco in Baltimore long term.

Unpredictability

We all remember the 11-year veteran leaving his playing status up in the air even after missing a mandatory minicamp last year. How do we know he won’t decide in a month that he wants to hang up his cleats for good? In the meantime any viable replacement on the free agent market has been gobbled up by other teams. Then there were the rumors of a locker room mutiny during the season where Reed, Pollard, and others questioned the decisions of Coach Harbaugh. Ed Reed marches to the beat of his own drummer, I get that, but this offseason for the Baltimore Ravens is crucial. Some of their biggest playmakers are free agents and Ray Lewis’ leadership is gone. The last thing they need is Reed wondering for months upon months whether he wants to keep playing or ride into the sunset as a Super Bowl champion.

Verdict

Ed Reed is not only one of the greatest Baltimore Ravens of all time but also one of the best safeties to ever play the game. His foundation has helped tons of local youth and his charity work has helped to make Baltimore a better place. Unfortunately, the NFL is a business and keeping a player on the downside of their career not only hurts your chances of winning on the field but it also hurts your chances of adding quality players in the offseason. This is arguably the most important offseason in Ravens history. At the “State of the Ravens” press conference Ozzie Newsome said their goal was to build a team to not just repeat but win multiple Lombardi trophies over the next decade. The only way to do that is to make difficult personal decisions.

Letting Ed Reed play elsewhere in 2013 will be the first of those difficult decisions.

This entry was posted in Blog View, Featured by Phil Gentile. Bookmark the permalink.

About Phil Gentile

Phil Gentile
Phil Gentile is the editor-in-chief of I Hate JJ Redick, an award winning Baltimore blog that covers Charm City's local sports teams in addition to fantasy sports, pro wrestling, music, movies, and everything in between. He is a self-confessed NFL Draft and fantasy football junkie and he's currently seeking weekly...more

4 Raves on “Time to say goodbye to Ed Reed

  1. ravenwoman on said:

    I totally agree with your blog. I stated the same thing in a post under the ravens 24×7 board. The problem with Baltimore fans is they fall in love with a player and live in the past. Ed Reed was a great safety. His physical abilities have declined and will continue to decline. One of the reasons the Patriots are so consistent with winning year in and year out is that they part with their players a year or two early, collect draft picks and re-load their team. We seem to keep players long past their prime, pay big money to them, just for the sake of the fan base. The QB is the most important position on a football team. We have to keep Joe Flacco and I believe we will, even at the expense of releasing legacy players.

  2. Stephens Dempsey on said:

    Reed needs to test the market to set the expectation and then the Ravens should present an offer if reasonable. He was the general of the defense last year, the consistant of the Raven way of Defense it would be nice to see him end his career here.

  3. Fernando Caprino on said:

    I think the Ravens should try to keep him. BUT at the right price… If he wants to stay and be paid a reasonable amount, fantastic, if not… Well, not much of an option anyways!

  4. Greg on said:

    I agree with many of the sentiments but you have to consider what he mentally brings to the ravens. His mere presence alone deters QBs, and he made big plays in the Super Bowl. his mental instincts were on full display when, during SF’s first goal line drive in the 1Q, he left coverage of the end zone to rush kapernick who was about to escape into the end zone. He forced a hasty and errant throw that boucned of Crabtree’s hands. That was a huge play that no one talks about. the vast majority of other safeties wouldn’t have diagnosed what was happening and would have been too late. Phil Simms astutely pointed it out too that Reed’s instant reaction and lightning charge enabled that errant throw. I know he can’t tackle quite like before or has the same range, but I think his contribution is underestimated now that his physical body isn’t the same. The real dilemma is whether we can match a big offer from the Colts or one of the other expected suitors. I think we would keep him on a 2-3 yr deal at or near his current salary maybe less, but if the Colts are willing to pay $8M for him, we’ll be priced out barring his desire to stay. I dont believe in the existence of hometown discounts rather there’s the realistic offer, and then the teams who will OVERpay.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

 

Hot off the street

Ravens Practice Squad

The Baltimore Ravens signed the following nine players to their practice squad Sunday afternoon: CB Tramain Jacobs, Rookie OL Ryan Jensen, 2nd year DT Jamie Meder, Rookie CB Deji Olatoye, Ro...read more

FILMSTUDY: Ravens Dominate Saints in Finale

By now, you know how much the Ravens dominated Thursday’s game versus the Saints: 79 offensive plays to 38 for the Saints (I believe that is a new team record fewest defensive snaps for any game...read more

Ravens 53-Man Squad: Unfinished Business?

OWINGS MILLS -- Some of the more interesting aspects of the Ravens’ 53-man roster that was announced Saturday: - Seven wide receivers were kept. Michael Campanaro, Kamar Aiken, and Deonte Thom...read more

Urschel In: “It’s a Dream Come True”

The Ravens faced some tough roster decisions today in regards to putting together their best 53 players who will battle each and every Sunday for their opportunity to win the Lombardi Trophy. As the ...read more

Ravens Trim to 53, More Moves Expected

The Ravens made several roster moves to get down to the mandated 53-man roster. Placed the following player on Physically Unable to Perform list: DT Terrence Cody Placed the following player...read more

View More